(500) Days of Summer-2009
Director Marc Webb
Starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Zooey Deschanel
Scott’s Review #1,002
Reviewed March 20, 2020
Grade: B
(500) Days of Summer (2009) is an unconventional love story that deserves props for being different, but never completely catches fire as a film effort.
What it tries to do left-of-center from most conventional romantic comedies is to be admired, but I did not feel much connection to the characters, and the result seemed pointless.
The independent film garnered some praise for being unique and clever. Still, it’s overshadowed by a gnawing, forced feeling, like the filmmakers are trying to be edgy for the sake of being edgy and adding contrived story elements.
The lead characters conveniently both like an obscure band and an obscure artist, throwing them immediately together.
The film is a modest effort but will only be remembered as an indie project with a bit of unfulfilled potential.
When his girlfriend, Summer (Zooey Deschanel), unceremoniously dumps him, greeting card copywriter and hopeless romantic Tom (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) spins into depression and begins reflecting on the year-long relationship the pair spent together, looking for clues as to what went wrong.
As he rummages through the good times and the bad times, his heart reawakens to find what is most important.
The Los Angeles backdrop sets the tone for the five hundred days of Tom and Summer.
Director Marc Webb, a first-time director at this point, now known more for The Amazing Spider-Man reboot franchise (2012-2014), steers in an experimental direction.
Shown somewhat like a “year in the life” of the young lovebirds’ blossoming relationship, the film is presented in a nonlinear narrative, jumping between various days within the five hundred days of Tom and Summer’s relationship.
There is an on-screen timer showing the day, which is a nice addition.
Props are given for the creativity Webb infuses. The romantic comedy genre, not my favorite, is constantly saturated with formulaic films, predictable from the start.
Frequently told from the female perspective, (500) Days of Summer tells the story from the male perspective, even reversing the traditional gender stereotypes. Tom is the lovesick romantic, and Summer is the rough-and-tumble, one-night-stand type.
This is nuanced and throws the entire genre upside down.
The characters are questionable, and the one easiest to relate to is Tom. There is some confusion and mystery with some motivations. The audience can understand how Tom falls head over heels for Summer, immediately smitten.
His depression is deep and to be taken seriously, but he is depressed because of Summer, and any history or previous causes of depression are not mentioned.
It feels like his depression is a convenient way of adding a story element.
Summer is even more perplexing and not deeply explored. Is she merely playing the field? After a song-and-dance scene where she explains she is not looking for anything serious and wants a casual romance, she suddenly marries another man.
She hurriedly tells Tom that she discovered her husband was her true love and that she now believes in love, whereas Tom doesn’t anymore.
Again, this feels more like storyline-dictated writing versus anything character-rich.
Despite receiving a Best Screenplay Independent Spirit Award nomination, two Golden Globe Award nominations, and oodles of praise, (500) Days of Summer (2009) is a non-conformist piece with some nice moments but feels irrelevant.
The lead actors are talented and do a decent job with the material given, but meander through the experience since it is more about the film than the acting.
The result is not a pure dud, but neither is it a pedigree winner.
Independent Spirit Award Nominations: 1 win-Best Feature, Best Male Lead-Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Best Screenplay (won)
