The Great Gatsby-1974

The Great Gatsby-1974

Director Jack Clayton

Starring Robert Redford, Mia Farrow

Scott’s Review #1,558

Reviewed November 16, 2026

Grade: B+

A 1974 adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic novel, The Great Gatsby, offers a haunting look at one steamy summer on lavish Long Island, New York during the 1920s.

The plot follows the financially struggling writer Nick Carraway, played by newcomer Sam Waterston, as he navigates his interactions with the mysterious millionaire Jay Gatsby (Robert Redford), his next-door neighbor.

This correlates with Gatsby’s obsession with reuniting with his former lover, Daisy Buchanan (Mia Farrow), who is a distant cousin of Nick’s.

Other romances brew between Daisy’s friend Jordan (Lois Chiles) and Nick, and Daisy’s husband Tom (Bruce Dern) and the local mechanic’s unstable wife, Myrtle (Karen Black).

The story unfolds amid the riotous Jazz Age parties Gatsby regularly hosts, featuring trendy dances like the Charleston, endless flowing champagne, and debauchery just twenty miles from New York City.

Nick narrates the story and immediately reveals his excitement at the start of the summer, presumably May, and by August he wishes the summer had never happened.

Even though I had read Fitzgerald’s novel, I was immediately engrossed in what would transpire next based on Nick’s revelation.

The foreboding mood wins with this film.

It begins with a nostalgic, romantic mood that gradually turns melancholy and tragic, highlighting the emptiness behind great wealth and the impossibility of reliving the past.

The parties and glamour are filled with revelry and glee but also mask a loneliness that most of the characters suffer.

The hot, sweaty atmosphere is perfect, as when Nick, Tom, Daisy, and Jordan go to Manhattan to cool off by sipping mint juleps and relaxing in a swanky hotel.

Meanwhile, back on Long Island, Myrtle nearly suffocates in the heat of her cramped upstairs bedroom in the mechanic shop as she longs for a permanent life in the city with the wealthy Tom.

A hovering giant billboard of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg’s (a fictional local optometrist) eyes is interpreted as a symbol of God watching over society and judging the characters.

It’s a fascinating addition.

So, the style and atmosphere of the 1974 effort are tremendously well done.

The actors all provide rich performances, especially Black, Waterston, and Dern.

Finally, the costumes ooze elegance and romance, perfectly capturing the 1920s, when it seemed like everyone had wealth, a sense of pizzazz, and nary a worry.

A perfect example is Daisy’s soft, flowing white gown at Gatsby’s party, which reflects the elegance of the Jazz Age. The light, delicate fabric sweeps effortlessly, making her the most prominent part of the party and naturally fills Gatsby with lust.

The film’s pacing is its weakness.

While I can champion slow-moving films with a tremendous payoff, which The Great Gatsby delivers with a startling climax, the film feels overly restrained and distant.

Despite so much drama, the energy level feels so low that the film drags along. The dreamy, nostalgic tone usurps the sluggish story. Despite feeling compelled, I also felt a bit bored throughout, which in turn felt strange.

Another criticism is with the main couple themselves. The chemistry between Redford and Farrow should be dynamic and full of sexual tension, but it’s weak. His supposed years-long obsession with her isn’t readily apparent on screen.

I was much more invested in characters like Tom, Myrtle, Wilson, Jordan, and Nick.

On the other hand, the 2013 version showcased tremendous chemistry between Leonardo DiCaprio and Carey Mulligan, though some had their complaints about the film itself.

The Great Gatsby (1974) is true to the novel but suffers from a slow burn and tedium amid fabulous costumes, set design, and performances.

Oscar Nominations: 2 wins-Best Cinematography, Best Art Direction-Set Decoration, Best Music, Scoring Original Song Score and/or Adaptation (won), Best Costume Design (won)

Golden Globe Nominations: 1 win-Best Supporting Actor-Bruce Dern, Sam Waterston, Best Supporting Actress-Karen Black (won), Most Promising Newcomer-Male-Sam Waterston

Leave a Reply