The Substance-2024
Director Coralie Fargeat
Starring Demi Moore, Margaret Qualley, Dennis Quaid
Scott’s Review #1,461
Reviewed January 18, 2025
Grade: A
Demi Moore takes her languishing career by the reigns in a risky role, leaving any glitz and glamour by the wayside in the wacky horror film The Substance (2024).
She also sheds her mainstream blockbuster image for darker cinematic territory, propelling her into a fresh new image.
Respectability.
The film received widespread critical acclaim, a gaspy crowd reaction, and buzz during awards season, making it the most talked-about film of the season.
Moore portrays a fading celebrity, Elisabeth Sparkle, who was fired by her producer (Dennis Quaid) on her fiftieth birthday due to her age.
She decides to use a black-market drug that creates a much younger version of herself (Margaret Qualley) with unexpected side effects.
As she drives home after being fired, she is involved in a car accident. She meets a handsome young nurse at the hospital who casually advertises a new product. He boldly tells her that it changed his life.
It creates a younger, more beautiful, more perfect you. The catch is that you share time, one week for one and one week for the other—an ideal balance of seven days each.
What could go wrong?
The film begins with a weird shot of a camera looking down at the creation of a famous star on Hollywood Boulevard where anyone who’s anyone has their name in a star on the famous street.
The sequence reveals that Elisabeth was once a big star. Workers sand her name on the sidewalk amid the celebration, and people stop in awe of her name. As the years go by, people comment that she was in some movie they can’t remember, and then someone callously spills garbage on her name, thinking nothing of it.
The story has powerful meaning about the societal pressures on women’s bodies and aging, especially in the media spotlight.
But this isn’t simply about women. Anyone of any gender or humanity can reflect on the insecurities of aging, whether in the corporate world or being cast aside for a younger person in any way.
I found The Substance incredibly relatable.
Besides the story, The Substance is directed very well by Coralie Fargeat, a French director I’d like to see more from.
She bravely incorporates snippets of Stanley Kubrick’s work, adding her funky weirdness and creating an insane experience for viewers.
Kubrick famously created long shots of hallways, which Fargeat brilliantly borrows. Elisabeth watches her producer and team rapidly walk towards her and reminds her that ‘pretty girls always smile,’ reinforcing ridiculous stereotypes attractive women are ‘supposed’ to follow.
Fargeat counterbalances the long shots with several close-ups, mainly of Moore staring at herself in the mirror. Seeing every wrinkle and blemish, she becomes increasingly obsessed with the younger version of herself.
The film does so much with very little dialogue, allowing Moore to deliver a performance of a lifetime.
As the film progresses, it becomes wackier and wackier in only the finest of ways as the older version becomes obsessed with her younger self. As she decays, she becomes a bald hunchback, unrecognizable.
At a diner, she runs into the older version of the young nurse, who admits that the process gets worse with each transformation.
The finale, set on New Year’s Eve, when Elisabeth is set to host events for millions to see, becomes horrific as her monster is set loose. A weird combination of human being and lumpy clay emerges on stage as Elisabeth begs the crowd to accept her.
The result is a moment that combines 1931’s Frankenstein with 1976’s Carrie as a horrific and quite bloody witch hunt ensues.
The film also reminds me of 2000’s Requiem for a Dream in style and in terms of addiction.
Fargeat, who directed, wrote, and produced the film, creates a feminist message that is awe-inspiring.
Combining unique camera angles that infuse a futuristic feel, astounding makeup work, and an exceptional performance by Moore makes The Substance (2024) the year’s surprise hit.
Independent Spirit Award Nominations: Best Feature, Best Lead Performance, Demi Moore